The Cimarron Hills club's real estate page lists Lot 132 at 403 Indigo Lane. It is 0.79 acres, priced at $299,000, and has no house on it. Inside the same gates, Newmark Homes' Fedrick Harris estate collection lists its Villa Carmel plan from $1,555,990 for 3,941 square feet. Elsewhere in the community, the Williamson Central Appraisal District gives an existing 4,274-square-foot home on 0.752 acres a 2026 market value of $1,574,810.
So an empty lot, a builder's starting price and an appraised existing home all sit within one community, and two of the three numbers land within about $20,000 of each other. Few luxury homes in this part of Georgetown change hands in a given month. Meanwhile, new construction inside the gates has put prices on public builder pages. A buyer looking at a resale in Cimarron Hills is comparing it, knowingly or not, to what the same money would build. That comparison lasts only as long as the last lots do.
The last 200 lots inside the gates
Cimarron Hills is on Hwy. 29 about six miles west of I-35. You enter on Jack Nicklaus Boulevard, named for the designer of the private course at its center. The final phase launched on May 23, 2025, and by that July Community Impact reported that more than 600 homes were built in the community. The new release added 200 estate lots of 0.5 to 1.9 acres, for custom homes starting at 3,500 square feet.
The release has two sections north of the existing homes. The Reserve has 84 lots, several of them backing up to the golf course. The Range has 116 lots, some with green space views. The developer is Forterra Developers. Community Impact listed six builders working the phase: Goodner Brothers, Grand Endeavor Homes, Sitterle Custom Homes, Atlas Custom Homes, Shiloh Homes and Gabriel CC Builders. Stephanie Duffin, Forterra's estate lot sales manager, told the outlet that lot price plus building cost could run from $1.5 million to $4 million or more, depending on the features buyers add.
Demand showed up early. By early July 2025, six weeks after launch, Forterra co-founder Ramakrishna Kandula told Community Impact that 65 lots were under contract or reserved and 135 were still available. Forterra's interactive lot map currently shows 102 lots as available, 35 sold, 33 under contract, 28 under review, 7 private and 1 reserved. Those statuses change as contracts move, so a buyer should look at the map the week they plan to act.
Three price points from one community
The posted prices fall into three groups, and they cover a wider range than the $1.5 million starting figure suggests.
The smallest new product is Sitterle's villa collection. Its page shows 100 Sunny Bell Ct, a 3,188-square-foot home in the Villas section, listed at $1,149,000 and marked available now. The middle group is Newmark's estate plans. They start with Villa Carmel at 3,941 square feet from $1,555,990, step through Villa Versailles, Villa Amalfi, Grand Villa Messina, Grand Villa Amalfi and Villa Rialto, and top out with Villa D'este at 5,995 square feet from $2,098,990. Newmark's one available home, 1109 Bobcat Bend, is a 5,827-square-foot, five-bedroom home listed at $2,312,990. Fully custom builds on the larger Reserve and Range lots make up the top group, and those run up to the $4 million-plus range Forterra described.
The existing homes sit against those numbers. Measured by price per square foot, that existing home's 2026 appraised value works out to about $368. Villa Carmel's starting price works out to about $395, before any options. These are not the same kind of number. An appraisal district market value is not a sale price, and a builder's "from" price is a starting point. Still, they are the two figures a buyer can find without help, and they tell a resale seller roughly where a buyer's alternative sits. A buyer at $1.6 million in Cimarron Hills can pick an established home on a mature lot today or a new plan with a construction timeline, and the costs land close together.
Why a builder's price list ends up as the comp
How few top-tier sales there are explains why posted builder prices matter this much. Community Impact's October 2026 market report, built on Unlock MLS data, counted 3 homes sold at $900,000 or more in the 78628 ZIP code, which includes Cimarron Hills. Another 9 sold between $700,000 and $899,999 that month. Across the three Georgetown ZIP codes the report covers, October 2026 had 200 closed sales, down from 215 in October 2025. New listings fell from 345 to 292, and average price per square foot slipped from $216 to $209. Median prices were down year over year in all three ZIP codes.
When a ZIP code records three sales above $900,000 in a month, each one carries a lot of weight, and some months may have none from inside the Cimarron Hills gates. An appraiser or a buyer's agent looking for evidence of value has a short list of closed sales to work with. Builders' published price lists fill the gap. They are public, they refresh as plans are repriced, and they describe homes in the same community with the same club behind them.
This pulls in two directions. When the wider market softens, as the October figures show, a resale priced well above what a comparable new plan would cost is hard to defend, because a buyer can see the alternative on a builder's website. A resale buyer also gets things a new build does not have yet, including landscaping that has had years to grow in, a known lot position on the course and no wait for construction. Those advantages are real, but a seller has to make the case for them, because the builder's list price is the number buyers will hold the listing against.
For a seller in the established sections, this is a pricing question more than a marketing one. A home valuation that leans only on area-wide closed sales will miss the most visible competition, which is the floor plans across the road.
What the comparison loses when the map fills in
Whenever the lot map runs out of available lots, Cimarron Hills will have no more new lots to sell. Once the phase sells through, the community's housing supply is the 600-plus homes that already existed plus whatever gets built on the 200 new lots. From then on, the only way into Cimarron Hills is to buy a resale from an owner who decides to sell.
Growth elsewhere in northwest Georgetown will not change that. Community Impact counted more than 8,500 new homes approved or proposed along Ronald Reagan Boulevard between Hwy. 195 and FM 3405. These come from Heirloom, Woodside, Somerset Hills, Parmer Ranch, Nolina and others. Heirloom's developer, Columnar Land vice president Logan Kimble, told the outlet his project would bring more accessible housing than the "larger lot" and "higher-end" homes typical of the area. That new construction is aimed at a different price tier. It adds retail and services nearby, such as the H-E-B at Parmer Ranch Marketplace, but it adds no half-acre-plus lots on a private Nicklaus course.
Timing therefore matters differently for each kind of buyer. A buyer who wants new construction inside these gates has a limited window to choose a lot and a builder. A buyer who prefers resale will eventually lose the builder price lists as a check on asking prices, and comps will come only from the occasional closed sale. An owner planning to sell in a few years may face less direct competition once the last spec homes are gone. That depends on the wider Georgetown market, which has softened over the past year.
The club costs to price into either path
Both paths carry the same club obligation. The club says every Cimarron Hills property owner must hold a Resident Social membership. Golf, Sport and Social memberships are separate tiers on top of that. The membership page lists no dollar amounts. It notes that Young Executive Golf members pay a reduced initiation fee, with the balance due at age 40 at the then-current Resident Golf rate. Legacy Golf Properties has owned the club since October 2022.
Ask the club for current dues, any fee charged when a home changes hands, and the golf initiation rate before you compare a resale price with a lot-plus-build total. Ask the homeowners association, Cimarron Hills Community Association, Inc., for any assessment it charges, and get that figure in writing too. Our earlier piece on how membership charters reprice Austin golf homes covers why those terms can matter as much as the price per square foot. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the club and association costs for your own purchase with the right professionals.
If you are deciding between a lot in The Reserve or The Range and an established home on the course, Thomas Luxury Group can compare a current resale with what builders inside the gates have posted, so you see both numbers before you commit. Request a private consultation, or browse our golf community homes to start.